Commercial mortgage brokers assist in most apartment loan transactions. Even investors who
have strong lender relationships can benefit from a broker’s familiarity with the current lending
environment and underwriting parameters. All of which help you get the best deal. Nonetheless,
it is important to ask the right questions to ensure that your broker is aligned with your priorities
and transparent about their role in the financing process. Below are some key questions you will
want to ask your broker to start the partnership on the right foot.
1. How Are You Compensated?
Mortgage brokers earn compensation through fees or yield spread premiums (sometimes both).
In the former case, the investor is paying the broker a fee that ranges from 0.50% to 1.50% of the
final loan amount. This is usually paid through escrow at loan closing. In the latter case, the
lender is paying the broker the amount of the “yield spread premium.” In other words, the broker
is being paid for selling you a higher interest rate over the lender’s wholesale rate.
Sometimes these yield spread premiums are undisclosed or hidden in the fine print. This
introduces a conflict of interest that may compromise your broker’s role as a fiduciary. If one
lender pays a yield spread premium and another doesn’t, you can imagine how that might
incentivize a mortgage broker to act against his client’s best interests by directing that client to
the lender that pays the referral fee. On the other hand, some brokers will waive or reduce their
fee when they are compensated by the lender. This means that an investor can reduce or
eliminate closing costs to the broker by effectively financing their fee with a higher interest rate.
Some lenders even show this math on the program/rate sheets that they share with brokers by
including options with negative loan fees or points. As you would expect, the rate increases with
the “negative” loan fees.
I recommend talking to your broker about compensation up front that way you aren’t questioning
their fidelity and you aren’t surprised at loan closing.
2. What Types of Lenders Are You Considering?
There are a few lender types that offer debt on apartments: balance sheet lenders (e.g.,
commercial banks like Chase or Wells Fargo), government sponsored entities (Freddie Mac,
Fannie Mae, FHA), and capital markets (life insurance companies, mortgage REITs, CMBS). A
single lender cannot offer competitive programs for all potential loans. As such, each type of
lender has different preferences that can lead to significant differences in quoted terms for the
same property. Furthermore, even lenders of the same type compete differently for loans. For example, if an investor is looking to refinance a $2 million loan, capital markets lenders will be a poor fit. Specifically, their execution is more costly and their preference for larger loans means
they won’t offer their best rate on this sized transaction. Worse yet, seeing it as a small opportunity, the lender won’t see you as a priority compared to their usual larger deals. Once you outline the needs of your loan, you should ask your broker how the lender types compare with respect to your loan and which type they feel will offer the best deal. This ensures the broker is considering all options, which is important since lenders move in and out of the market. For
example, Freddie Mac introduced their small balance program in late 2014. A broker accustomed to working with banks on smaller loans may not consider agency options as they historically weren’t as competitive on smaller loans.
Even small differences in rates can compound given the size of most commercial real estate
loans. Consequently, it can save an investor tens of thousands of dollars to find the most
competitive lender for their property.
3. Will the Loan Be Recourse?
An investor who prefers non-recourse or is unable to provide a personal guaranty due to the
nature of their ownership structure should let their broker know early in the process. As
mentioned above, the best type of lender will vary based on recourse or non-recourse. Capital
markets providers and agency lenders are keener on non-recourse, whereas banks generally
prefer recourse. Even if you are willing to provide a personal guaranty, you should ensure that
your rate is lower to reflect the benefit of your guaranty compared to a non-recourse structure.
See my previous article “Recourse: What’s the value of your signature” for a discussion on the
merits of recourse vs. non-recourse.
Discussing your recourse preference early helps the broker prudently find the best lender for
4. Can I Pay Off My Loan Early?
Most commercial mortgages have a prepayment “premium” or penalty that lasts about as long as
the fixed rate term. This means if you pay off your loan before the end of the penalty period,
you’ll have to pay a fee that ranges between 0.5% to 5.0% of the amount that you prepay. This is
a considerable cost that can stymie your investment strategy whether you intend to sell or
refinance for a lower rate. Not only should you know if there is a proposed prepayment penalty
on the new loan, but you should evaluate any existing loan for prepayment amounts due upon
refinancing. As mentioned in my previous article “5 Common and Costly Refinancing
Mistakes,” an existing prepayment premium can pose a costly surprise that rears its head after
committing to new financing. In addition, when considering your new loan, you want to consider
the new prepayment premium relative to your investment strategy. If you intend to renovate the
property and refinance to pull out the new equity, you will want a shorter prepayment premium
that allows you to refinance within a couple of years. On the other hand, if you intend to stay put
for a while, you might be more comfortable with a longer prepayment penalty duration in
exchange for a longer fixed rate period or other structural benefit. Keep in mind that prepayment
penalties do not allow flexibility if (when) things change. As such, you may want to negotiate in
a waiver in the event of refinance with the same lender or sale of the property to a third party.
The key thing is to have this discussion with your broker early so they can incorporate your
strategy in when searching for your optimal lender.
5. What are the Total Expected Costs to Close the Loan?
Many investors focus on the interest rate, but a broker will help you focus and compare other
refinancing costs. How much is the good faith deposit? Is there a rate lock fee or is it a deposit?
What are the expected third party costs for legal, appraisal, and environmental? These are all
questions an investor should be asking their broker when comparing lenders. If comparing
lenders by rate alone, an investor may miss other costs that make the all-in borrowing cost higher
Make sure that your broker includes a breakout of fees in their comparison presentation. You’re
not getting a comparison presentation? You might want to find a new broker.
6. Have You Closed a Loan Like Mine With Your Recommended Lender?
You want to know if your broker has worked with this lender before. It’s fine if they haven’t,
since there are many lenders in the market, but the broker’s previous experience may help you
decide between lender options. One lender may have the best rate, but your broker might tell you
that their closing process is more arduous or that they ask for every Schedule K-1 for the past 3-
years. It might be worth the initial headache to get the better rate or other structural feature, but
the important thing is to set your expectations accordingly so that you can close your loan
smoothly with minimal surprises.
Most brokers want to help you find the best loan for your property, but to do so, they must
understand your needs. Asking these questions fosters conversation that helps build that
understanding early and, in the end, helps your broker find you the best loan.
Nick Schoch is an independent loan advisor for 5+ unit apartments and a
landlord located in San Diego, CA. You can download Nick’s Apartment
Financing Handbook and related tools for free at his website: nickschoch.com.
If you have questions about this article or financing an existing property or
purchase, you can contact Nick at [email protected] or call/text (760) 201-