capital improvements cash flow

While California policymakers express concern about housing shortages, their own tax policies are locking up real estate inventory.

Housing providers in Southern California face an increasingly challenging landscape, marked by tenant-favored regulations that penalize property investors at every turn. From Los Angeles’ strict rent control measures to statewide tenant protection laws—and new local taxes like Measure ULA—rental property owners must navigate an ever-growing list of restrictions and taxations. Many investors would love to sell and cash out—but feel trapped by the significant capital gains tax they would owe upon selling. As a result, inventory remains scarce, driving prices higher and further worsening the housing affordability crisis.

Is There a Way Out?

Is it fair for the government to tax the same real estate asset multiple times? And if this approach changed, could it be the key to unlocking more inventory and creating a healthier, more balanced housing market?

The TV vs. Real Estate Test

When you compare how real estate is taxed compared to, for example, how a television is taxed when purchased: you pay sales tax once on the TV. Done. The government doesn’t show up year after year demanding more money for the same TV. This reflects a basic American principle—once you’ve paid your transaction tax, your private property should remain yours without ongoing government interference.

The Triple-Tax Trap

Real estate, however, operates under a very different—and arguably excessive—system. Investors pay transfer taxes when they buy, property taxes every year they own, and capital gains taxes when they sell. That’s triple taxation on a single asset. You never truly “own” real estate free and clear; even after 35 years, you’re still paying to keep it. And when you finally do sell, the government taxes the appreciation—despite having already taxed you annually through property taxes.

- Advertisers -

This structure creates a counterproductive incentive. Rather than selling to new investors and increasing inventory, owners hold on to their properties indefinitely to avoid a large tax hit. The result? Fewer transactions, less inventory, and continued upward pressure on home prices—further fueling the affordability crisis.

A Question of Constitutionality

Our founding fathers opposed direct taxation on property for precisely this reason—they understood that repeated taxation on the same asset erodes economic freedom. Unlike consumption taxes, which you can avoid by choosing not to buy, real estate investors have no way to reduce or opt out of this layered tax burden. It’s taxation without the protection of economic choice.

California’s Self-Inflicted Housing Crisis

This tax-driven inventory freeze is a key contributor to California’s affordability crisis. Long-term housing providers sit on properties that could be revitalized by new ownership, while policymakers continue to question why inventory remains so tight.

California urgently needs a more dynamic housing market—with more available real estate and more investment—yet its tax structure actively discourages the very property transfers that could help free up inventory and create a more balanced market.

A Simple, Effective Solution

Eliminating capital gains tax on long-held investment properties would immediately unlock inventory. Housing providers would gain the flexibility to sell, and long-owned properties could be passed on to new investors bringing fresh capital and new opportunities for the younger generation.

The Bottom Line

Investing in real estate is already a risk-heavy endeavor, especially in tenant-friendly markets like California. Triple taxation—via transfer taxes, ongoing property taxes, and capital gains taxes—creates a system that discourages turnover and locks up desperately needed inventory.  California’s housing crisis isn’t just a result of zoning and regulation. It’s a tax problem.

What’s Your Take?

Is it fair to pay transfer taxes when you buy, property taxes every year you own, and capital gains taxes when you sell?  Is capital gains tax the only thing keeping you from cashing out?  I’d love to hear your perspective—and any ideas you’d offer for creating a more balanced system.

Mercedes Shaffer is a multifamily broker with REAL, and if you have questions about buying, selling or doing a 1031 exchange, her  team serves LA and Orange County and can be reached at 714.330.9999, [email protected], or you can visit their website at InvestingInTheOC.com  BRE 02114448.

This article is intended for educational and discussion purposes. It is not intended as tax or legal advice. Please consult your CPA or attorney for those matters.