The City of Healdsburg, California, has agreed to settle a lawsuit filed less than two months ago by Jessica Pilling, a local mom represented by Pacific Legal Foundation. Jessica sued the City in September over its “inclusionary housing” ordinance, which tacked a $20,000 fee onto her family’s homebuilding project. The City has now refunded the fee.
Here’s how inclusionary housing (also called inclusionary zoning) works: If you want to get a permit to build a new home or apartment building, you have to pay a fee or dedicate land to affordable housing. About a third of California cities have inclusionary housing ordinances. On paper, these policies are designed to increase affordable housing. In reality, they make housing less affordable: A 2015 study found that California cities with inclusionary housing ordinances ended up with 20 percent higher housing prices and 7 percent fewer homes than cities without.
The Pillings’ experience with inclusionary housing was especially absurd—because they themselves qualify for affordable housing in Healdsburg, which is a wealthy area in Sonoma County. Inclusionary housing is meant to help people like them find homes. But in order for the Pillings to build a home, they had to pay the City a steep inclusionary housing fee – making their homebuilding project decidedly less affordable and achievable.
Pacific Legal Foundation filed Jessica’s lawsuit in September.“Mrs. Pilling’s Project does not have any negative impact on the affordability of homes in the City,” PLF argued in its complaint. “On the contrary, elementary principles of economics demonstrate that by building new housing units, the Project increases supply and therefore lowers—not raises—prices.”
Less than two months later, Healdsburg agreed to pay $35,000 to settle with the Pillings—$30,000 to refund the couple for the fee and compensate them for their hardship; $5,000 to PLF for attorneys’ fees. (PLF represents all our clients free of charge but can recover attorneys’ fees from the government.)
The settlement is a solution that makes it easier for the Pillings to build. That’s a clear victory—for the Pillings, for homebuyers and renters in the Healdsburg area, and for the City itself, whether officials realize it or not.


