The below article was written by Attorney Daniel Bornstein, Esq. of Bornstein Law.
Efforts to axe the Costa-Hawkins Rental House Act of 1995 have thus far been unsuccessful, but this time around it has more than a fighting chance.
We’ve probably all heard by now that Michael Weinstein, the sharp-elbowed president of
the AIDS Healthcare Foundation (AHF), is back with yet another attempt to repeal Costa-Hawkins, the decades-old state law that exempts certain properties from rent control and allows landlords to set rent prices to whatever the market will bear once the unit is vacant (“vacancy decontrol”). Battle lines have been drawn for and against the so-called “Renters for Justice Act.”
Some Background is in Order
In 1995, the year Costa-Hawkins was passed, California’s government was a blend of lawmakers of various political persuasions, with many moderates having a voice in shaping public policy. Costa-Hawkins would never pass today when more than 40% of Californians are renters and lawmakers have to appeal to them to advance their political careers.
Weinstein and his organization amassed hundreds of thousands of signatures in short order and
easily surpassed the number required to qualify for the November 2024 ballot. As reported by Politico, the polarizing nonprofit honcho paid out $2 for every signature obtained to support the ballot initiative. After asking someone, “Is the rent too high?”, obtaining their signature was easy enough to do.
Past measures that would have tampered with Costa-Hawkins have failed by a wide margin. What’s different this time around? Rent-burdened voters. The failed Props 10 and 21 would have made specific modifications to the longstanding law, but the goals were not to repeal it altogether. Without the safeguards of Costa-Hawkins, cities already operating under rent control will reel back to a time of strict rent control, when a considerable amount of housing stock was lost as owners took rentals off the market.
Another consequence before Costa-Hawkins was deferred maintenance. There were no financial
incentives for landlords to maintain their buildings, much less improve and beautify them.
Although Props 10 and 21 were voted down, we are concerned about voters struggling to make ends meet with rising costs. Stronger renter protections are now more frequent in corners
of suburbia that were once removed from the activism we only expected to see in progressive cities like San Francisco and Berkeley.
When we first began our legal careers some 26 years ago, we “only” had to contend with three
rent ordinances, those in San Francisco, in Oakland, and in Berkeley. Since then, however, greater tenant protections have expanded well outside these urban centers. Calls for rent control continue to proliferate, with Larkspur, Pittsburg, San Pablo, Redwood City, and Concord among California locales with more rent and eviction controls being advocated.
Rallying the Troops to Defeat Weinstein 3.0
[Many apartment associations, the California Business Roundtable and AOA], are all strapped in for an epic battle over the Justice for Renters Act ballot initiative. Fortunately, there are brilliant political strategists behind the campaign to defeat the ballot measure.
On the other hand, however, it’s going to be an arduous battle requiring tens of millions of
dollars. We were alarmed to see early poll results. Even if respondents were not rent-burdened, they know someone who has a financial hardship, and so a staggering number of people polled were in favor of statewide rent control. We don’t want to reveal exact numbers and alert those on
the competing side.
Interestingly, however, the pro-rent control numbers shrink when the question is phrased differently. When asked if they conceptually support the idea of local governments having more authority to impose increased regulations on housing providers, far fewer respondents were behind it. Our takeaway is that the messaging has to be nailed down, that this will be a war of words.
Weinstein’s Most Compelling Argument?
What resonates with likely voters is that billion-dollar corporations outside of California are gobbling up housing stock and raising the rents to unaffordable levels to increase profit.
What is the greatest messaging to provide a counternarrative? That is being planned and fine-
tuned through research, focus groups, etc., but clearly, it should be articulated that the repeal of Costa-Hawkins would hurt smaller “mom-and-pop” landlords.
Another interesting argument we haven’t heard of: it will drive more Californians out of the state. Governor Newsom has touted and anticipated changing the state’s budget deficit to a budget surplus due to increased revenue. Translation: more taxes. While it can be debated who is paying their fair share of taxes, what is not up for debate is that Californians who leave the state won’t pay their fair share of taxes; they won’t be paying taxes at all.
Republicans Must Be Galvanized to Vote in Full Force
In a state that’s solidly blue, Republicans do not influence the presidential race, but they can make an impact in thwarting Weinstein’s efforts. Republicans represent the smallest voting bloc, but overwhelmingly they’re allies of rental housing providers in opposing the Justice for Renters Act.
Many militant Democrats and tenants’ activists will not budge on their vote, which leaves more moderate, sober-minded Democrats and independents, who are open to hearing out the concerns of housing providers. The political operatives conducting the polls have articulated a pathway to defeating the measure, but after the numbers are crunched, victory would come with a razor-thin margin.
What Can Housing Providers Do?
In our view, our industry partners have done a good job of educating the rental housing community about the campaign underway to strip landlords of their rights, but this is not enough. Of course, housing providers will vote NO for the ballot measure come November. They are a friendly audience. We need to talk to people less informed. In a grassroots effort, we need to win over the hearts and minds of voters who are undecided or do not recognize the detriment to renters if Costa-Hawkins is repealed.
As the gears start meshing, we’ll share updated materials and language to use when corresponding with family, friends, neighbors, and influencers. What would go a long way in dispelling Weinstein’s portrayal of housing providers as “greed-fueled speculators” are accounts, preferably video accounts, of the hardships faced by small landlords. We want to convey that small landlords care deeply about the communities in which they live and are the greatest
engine of clean, safe, and affordable housing. Large corporations and REITS do not have a friendly face, but mom and pops do.
06Finally, Consider Donating to the Cause
It’s going to take vast resources to stop this measure, including a lot of airtime and social media involvement. For those of you who say November is far in the future, keep in mind that substantial savings can be realized when media buys are made early. Some “early bird” savings can be up to 50%. Also, remember that in a Presidential race year and with other hotly-con measures up for voters to decide on, political ads will be plastered everywhere in the weeks leading up to November and the price will go up. Better to lock in lower rates early on than to wait for a crowded field to drive up the costs of getting our crucial message out.
With the race projected to be a nail-biter, it’s that much more important that we build our war chest, articulate and broadcast our message, and work overtime to ensure that Costa-Hawkins remains the law of the land.W???
[AOA’s Note: According to Ballotpedia – https://ballotpedia.org/California_Prohibit_State_Limitations_on_Local_Rent_Control_Initiative_(2024), the AIDS Foundation has earmarked over $10,000,000 to promote this proposition. Unfortunately, all of the associations put together have only raised $1,000,000. Please donate NOW. Every rental property owner needs to contribute at least $1,000 to oppose this ballot measure. We beat Weinstein before on this and we HAVE to do it again! Please, please donate NOW! You can contribute online at https://aoausa.com/pac/ or mail your check made payable and addressed to AOA PAC to 6445 Sepulveda, Suite 100, Van Nuys, CA 91411.]
As the founding attorney of Bornstein Law, Daniel is a well-respected authority in landlord-tenant disputes and property management issues. With over 23 years of experience in handling real estate and civil litigation throughout the Bay Area, he also manages rental properties, is instrumental in completing real estate transactions and is renowned for his educational seminars. For more information, visit www.bornstein.law or call 415-409-7611 or email: [email protected].

